Definition of backtesting

Share This Post

Backtesting is a vital process in financial analysis that helps investors evaluate the accuracy and effectiveness of their investment strategies. It is a statistical method that tests an investment strategy by applying it to historical data to determine how it would have performed in the past.

Here is a short summary on backtesting:
Backtesting evaluates trading strategies using historical data, assessing their viability and risks for informed investment decisions.

Lazy to read? This video does a great job explaining how to backtest properly

Backtesting properly

What Is Backtesting?

Backtesting is the general method for seeing how well a strategy or model would have done ex-post. Backtesting assesses the viability of a trading strategy by discovering how it would play out using historical data. If backtesting works, traders and analysts may have the confidence to employ it going forward.

Importance

Backtesting is an essential step in the investment process since it provides investors with insights into how their investment strategies would have performed in the past. By analyzing historical data, investors can evaluate how their strategies have performed in different market conditions, identify strengths and weaknesses, and adjust their strategies accordingly.

Backtesting serves as a valuable tool in deciphering historical market behaviors, offering statistical insights into a trading system’s performance. This process plays a crucial role in measuring risk and potential returns, paving the way for more effective trading decisions. By utilizing backtesting, traders have the opportunity to evaluate and compare various strategies without immediately committing their capital.

When conducted meticulously, and if it yields encouraging outcomes, backtesting can affirm the foundational robustness of a trading strategy. This reassurance empowers traders to proceed with confidence, as the strategy demonstrates a high likelihood of success in real market conditions.

Conversely, a thorough backtesting process that does not meet expected results is equally informative. It signals traders to reconsider their approach, inviting them to refine or possibly discard the strategy under review. This critical feedback loop ensures that traders are more informed and cautious in their strategy selection, ultimately aiming to enhance their chances of successful trading.

How Backtesting Works

Backtesting allows a trader to simulate a trading strategy using historical data to generate results and analyze risk and profitability before risking any actual capital.

Works by applying an investment strategy to historical data to determine how it would have performed in the past. The process involves selecting a time period, defining the investment strategy, and applying it to the historical data. The results of the backtesting process are then analyzed to evaluate the effectiveness of the investment strategy.

To delve deeper into how backtesting operates, it is crucial to understand that it allows traders to simulate a chosen strategy using historical data, offering a simulated environment to analyze risk and profitability without risking actual capital. However, the effectiveness of backtesting is contingent on the selected time period, the definition of the investment strategy, and the meticulous application of the strategy to historical data.

Understanding Backtesting:

Exploring Backtesting in Trading Backtesting enables traders to test their trading strategies using past market data, assessing both risk and potential profitability before investing real money.

When backtesting yields favorable outcomes, it reassures traders that their strategy has a solid foundation and stands a good chance of being profitable in real-world trading. On the other hand, if the backtesting results are less than ideal, it prompts traders to modify or abandon the strategy.

Complex trading strategies, particularly those used in automated trading systems, depend heavily on backtesting for validation, as their intricacies make them difficult to assess by other means. Any tradable idea, if it can be quantified, is eligible for backtesting. Traders and investors might sometimes require the skills of a proficient programmer to transform their ideas into a format suitable for backtesting. This usually involves programming the strategy into the specific language used by the trading platform.

Programmers can add customizable input options for the trader to adjust the strategy. For instance, in a simple moving average (SMA) crossover system, a trader can input different lengths for the two moving averages used. The trader can then backtest these variations to find out which combination of moving average lengths would have been most effective using historical data.

Optimizing Backtesting for Reliable Results

A thorough backtesting process should ideally select data from a period that accurately represents various market conditions. This approach helps in determining if the backtest results are consistently reliable or merely a stroke of luck.

For a backtest to be effective, it’s crucial to use a dataset that encompasses a wide range of stocks, including those from companies that failed, were acquired, or ceased operations. Limiting the dataset to currently successful stocks could lead to an overestimation of potential returns, as it excludes the full spectrum of possible outcomes. Websites like Investopedia and QuantConnect offer insights on selecting appropriate datasets for backtesting.

It’s also important to factor in all trading costs in the backtest, no matter how small they may seem. Over time, these costs can significantly impact the perceived profitability of a strategy. Resources like BabyPips and Quantpedia provide information on how to accurately include trading costs in backtesting scenarios.

Additionally, conducting out-of-sample and forward performance testing can give further evidence of a system’s efficacy. These tests can reveal the true potential of a trading strategy before real money is involved. A consistent performance across backtesting, out-of-sample, and forward tests is a strong indicator of a strategy’s viability. Websites like QuantStart and Elite Trader offer guidance on implementing these additional testing methods effectively.

In summary, for backtesting to be truly beneficial, it must encompass a comprehensive and realistic approach, considering varied data, all trading costs, and additional testing phases.

Navigating the Challenges of Backtesting

Effective backtesting requires traders to approach strategy development and testing with integrity and an objective mindset. It’s essential to create trading strategies independently from the data used in backtesting to avoid biased results. This objective approach can be challenging, as traders often rely on historical data to shape their strategies. To ensure accuracy, it’s crucial to test these strategies with different datasets than those used during their development. This prevents the common pitfall of backtests showing overly optimistic results that don’t translate into real-world success.

Additionally, traders should be wary of data dredging. This practice involves testing numerous hypothetical strategies against the same dataset, which can misleadingly indicate success due to random chance rather than genuine strategy effectiveness. Many strategies might appear successful over a specific period by chance, but they may not hold up in actual market conditions.

A constructive approach to mitigate these issues is to apply a two-phase testing process. First, validate the strategy with an in-sample (relevant time period) dataset, and then conduct a backtest using a different, out-of-sample dataset. Consistency in performance across both in-sample and out-of-sample backtests can significantly enhance the credibility of the strategy’s effectiveness. This method provides a more robust and reliable evaluation of a trading strategy’s potential success.

Examples Of Backtesting

In the realm of finance, backtesting is a pivotal tool that allows traders and analysts to evaluate investment strategies using historical data. A visual representation captures this process, showing a financial analyst at work, surrounded by screens displaying stock market charts and data, emblematic of the detailed analysis inherent in backtesting. Through examples, such as an intraday trader testing a 30-day low stock purchase strategy and a team of traders exploring various methods for balanced returns, we see backtesting’s crucial role in refining and developing effective investment strategies, demonstrating its indispensable value in financial decision-making.

Example 1: Intraday Trading Strategy Evaluation

A scenario involves an intraday trader at a major investment firm. The firm’s objective is to evaluate a new trading strategy: purchasing stocks at their 30-day low point to see if it leads to a positive return. The trader gathers extensive historical data on numerous stocks and applies this strategy retrospectively.

Upon analysis, the strategy outperforms the firm’s existing approach by an average of 60 points. This significant improvement leads the firm to adopt this strategy for future trades, with plans to adjust it as needed based on ongoing return on investment assessments.

Example 2: Agency Team’s Diverse Strategy Analysis

In this case, a team of traders at an agency embarks on a backtesting project. Their aim is to find an optimal strategy that balances medium risk with high returns, employing various underutilized investment tactics. They meticulously analyze five years of market data, incorporating technical analysis, financial reports, and yearly market sentiment.

Their exhaustive testing reveals that several strategies result in negative returns. However, perseverance pays off when they discover a method yielding a 50-point profit. This finding is then presented to the agency’s lead investor for further decision-making and potential implementation.

These examples illustrate how backtesting is utilized in the financial world to refine and develop effective investment strategies.

To create a comprehensive table featuring different types of alternative data, their typical costs, and usefulness in investing, I’ll outline a format and then populate it with relevant information.

Benefits and added insights

provides investors with several benefits, including:

  • Identifying potential risks and weaknesses of a strategy before investing real money
  • Improving the accuracy of investment decisions by providing insights into how a strategy would have performed in different market conditions
  • Reducing the risk of investment losses by identifying potential pitfalls in the investment strategy before implementing it
  • Enhancing the overall performance of the investment portfolio by enabling investors to fine-tune their investment strategies

While the benefits of backtesting are extensive, it’s essential to highlight its role in identifying potential risks and weaknesses before actual capital is invested. Furthermore, the accuracy of investment decisions is significantly improved by gaining insights into how a strategy would have performed in various market conditions. Investors can leverage this information to fine-tune their strategies, ultimately enhancing the overall performance of their investment portfolios.

What Are the Main Points to Consider in Backtesting?

There are three major points to consider when conducting a backtest. Backtesting typically requires a specific trading strategy or idea, historical data, and measures on returns.

Expanding on the three major points to consider during a backtest, the significance of the trading strategy cannot be overstated. The meticulous selection of a strategy determines the type and duration of data collected, influencing the robustness of the backtesting process.

Trading Strategy

Picking a trading strategy is the first step in backtesting. This will determine what type of data will be collected and for how long.

Data

Collecting accurate data is important in backtesting. Data should be free of errors, and results from backtesting will depend on the type of historical data selected.

Key Performance Indicators

Key performance indicators are used to determine whether the performance of a trading strategy results in a profit or loss. Some of the common KPIs include total return, annualized return, and the Sharpe ratio.

To further bolster the evaluation process, the incorporation of key performance indicators (KPIs) is essential. These metrics, such as total return, annualized return, and the Sharpe ratio, play a pivotal role in determining the profitability and effectiveness of a trading strategy.

Limitations of Backtesting

Although it is a useful tool, it is not without limitations. One of the most significant limitations is that it is based on historical data, which may not accurately reflect future market conditions. Additionally, backtesting assumes that investors would have acted consistently in the past, which may not always be the case.

While acknowledging the importance of backtesting, it’s crucial to recognize its limitations. Historical data, upon which backtesting relies, may not always accurately reflect future market conditions. Additionally, traders must guard against pitfalls such as bias, data dredging, and cherry-picking strategies based on historical data.

Some Pitfalls of Backtesting

For backtesting to provide meaningful results, traders must develop their strategies and test them in good faith, avoiding bias as much as possible. That means the strategy should be developed without relying on the data used in backtesting.

That’s harder than it seems. Traders generally build strategies based on historical data. They must be strict about testing with different data sets from those they train their models on. Otherwise, the backtest will produce glowing results that mean nothing.

Similarly, traders must avoid data dredging, in which they test a wide range of hypothetical strategies against the same set of data, which will also produce successes that fail in real-time markets because there are many invalid strategies that would beat the market over a specific time period by chance.

One way to compensate for the tendency to data dredge or cherry-pick is to use a strategy that succeeds in the relevant, or in-sample, time period and backtest it with data from a different, or out-of-sample, time period. If in-sample and out-of-sample backtests yield similar results, then they are more likely to be proved valid.

FAQ: Understanding and Performing Backtesting in Trading

How do you perform backtesting?

Backtesting involves simulating a trading strategy using historical market data to evaluate its performance. This process typically includes selecting a time period, obtaining relevant historical data, defining specific rules for your trading strategy, and then applying these rules against the data to observe how the strategy would have performed. Don’t forget to include transaction costs and ensure the data is free of biases. For a comprehensive guide on backtesting, visit Investopedia: Investopedia Backtesting Guide or QuantInsti: QuantInsti Backtesting Resources.

What is an example of a backtest strategy?

A common example is the Moving Average Crossover strategy. This involves using two moving averages of a security’s price – a short-term and a long-term average. A trade signal is generated when these averages cross. For detailed examples and explanations, check out DailyFX: DailyFX Moving Average Strategies.

What is backtesting a model?

Backtesting a model involves testing a predictive model or trading algorithm using historical data to evaluate its accuracy in predicting future events. This is crucial in financial markets for validating trading decisions. For more in-depth information, consider exploring quantitative analysis websites and financial modeling courses.

Where can I backtest my strategy?

You can backtest on platforms like TradingView (TradingView), MetaTrader (MetaTrader), QuantConnect (QuantConnect), and NinjaTrader (NinjaTrader). Each platform offers unique features suitable for different levels of trading experience.

How do I backtest using TradingView?

On TradingView, use the Pine Script language to create custom trading strategy scripts for backtesting. After scripting your strategy, apply it to historical data on the platform. TradingView’s forums and Pine Script documentation provide resources for scripting and implementation: TradingView Pine Script Documentation.

How can I backtest forex?

Backtesting a forex strategy requires historical forex market data and clear trade entry and exit rules. Platforms like MetaTrader are popular for forex backtesting, offering tools for strategy development and testing. For tutorials on forex backtesting, visit BabyPips: BabyPips Forex Backtesting.

These links offer valuable insights and tools for anyone interested in learning more about backtesting and its application in trading strategies.

Conclusion

In conclusion, backtesting is a crucial tool for investors seeking to evaluate the effectiveness of their investment strategies. By analyzing historical data, investors can identify potential risks and weaknesses, fine-tune their strategies, and make better investment decisions. As such, investors should always include backtesting as a critical step in their investment process.

More To Explore

Alan Kwan

Alan joined ExtractAlpha in 2024. He is a tenured associate professor of finance at the University of Hong Kong, where he serves as the program director of the MFFinTech, teaches classes on quantitative trading and big data in finance, and conducts research in finance specializing in big data and alternative datasets. He has published research in prestigious journals and regularly presents at financial conferences. He previously worked in technical and trading roles at DC Energy, Bridgewater Associates, Microsoft and advises several fintech startups. He received his PhD in finance from Cornell and his Bachelors from Dartmouth.

John Chen

John joined ExtractAlpha in 2023 as the Director of Partnerships & Customer Success. He has extensive experience in the financial information services industry, having previously served as a Director of Client Specialist at Refinitiv. John holds dual Bachelor’s degrees in Commerce and Architecture (Design) from The University of Melbourne.

Chloe Miao

Chloe joined ExtractAlpha in 2023. Prior to joining, she was an associate director at Value Search Asia Limited. She earned her Masters of Arts in Global Communications from the Chinese University of Hong Kong.

Matija Ratkovic

Matija is a specialist in software sales and customer success, bringing experience from various industries. His career, before sales, includes tech support, software development, and managerial roles. He earned his BSc and Specialist Degree in Electrical Engineering at the University of Montenegro.

Jack Kim

Jack joined ExtractAlpha in 2022. Previously, he spent 20+ years supporting pre- and after-sales activities to drive sales in the Asia Pacific market. He has worked in many different industries including, technology, financial services, and manufacturing, where he developed excellent customer relationship management skills. He received his Bachelor of Business in Operations Management from the University of Technology Sydney.

Perry Stupp

Perry brings more than 20 years of Enterprise Software development, sales and customer engagement experience focused on Fortune 1000 customers. Prior to joining ExtractAlpha as a Technical Consultant, Perry was the founder, President and Chief Customer Officer at Solution Labs Inc. a data analytics company that specialized in the analysis of very large-scale computing infrastructures in place at some of the largest corporate data centers in the world.

Perry Stupp

Perry brings more than 20 years of Enterprise Software development, sales and customer engagement experience focused on Fortune 1000 customers. Prior to joining ExtractAlpha as a Technical Consultant, Perry was the founder, President and Chief Customer Officer at Solution Labs Inc. a data analytics company that specialized in the analysis of very large-scale computing infrastructures in place at some of the largest corporate data centers in the world.

Janette Ho

Janette has 22+ years of leadership and management experience in FinTech and analytics sales and business development in the Asia Pacific region. In addition to expertise in quantitative models, she has worked on risk management, portfolio attribution, fund accounting, and custodian services. Janette is currently head of relationship management at Moody’s Analytics in the Asia-Pacific region, and was formerly Managing Director at State Street, head of sales for APAC Asset Management at Thomson Reuters, and head of Asia for StarMine. She is also a board member at Human Financial, a FinTech firm focused on the Australian superannuation industry.

Leigh Drogen

Leigh founded Estimize in 2011. Prior to Estimize, Leigh ran Surfview Capital, a New York based quantitative investment management firm trading medium frequency momentum strategies. He was also an early member of the team at StockTwits where he worked on product and business development.  Leigh is now the CEO of StarKiller Capital, an institutional investment management firm in the digital asset space.

Andrew Barry

Andrew is the CEO of Human Financial, a technology innovator that is pioneering consumer-led solutions for the superannuation industry. Andrew was previously CEO of Alpha Beta, a global quant hedge fund business. Prior to Alpha Beta he held senior roles in a number of hedge funds globally.

Natallia Brui

Natallia has 7+ years experience as an IT professional. She currently manages our Estimize platform. Natallia earned a BS in Computer & Information Science in Baruch College and BS in Economics from BSEU in Belarus. She has a background in finance, cybersecurity and data analytics.

June Cook

June has a background in B2B sales, market research, and analytics. She has 10 years of sales experience in healthcare, private equity M&A, and the tech industry. She holds a B.B.A. from Temple University and an M.S. in Management and Leadership from Western Governors University.

Jenny Zhou, PhD

Jenny joined ExtractAlpha in 2023. Prior to that, she worked as a quantitative researcher for Chorus, a hedge fund under AXA Investment Managers. Jenny received her PhD in finance from the University of Hong Kong in 2023. Her research covers ESG, natural language processing, and market microstructure. Jenny received her Bachelor degree in Finance from The Chinese University of Hong Kong in 2019. Her research has been published in the Journal of Financial Markets.

Kristen Gavazzi

Kristen joined ExtractAlpha in 2021 as a Sales Director. As a past employee of StarMine, Kristen has extensive experience in analyst performance analytics and helped to build out the sell-side solution, StarMine Monitor. She received her BS in Business Management from Cornell University.

Triloke Rajbhandary

Triloke has 10+ years experience in designing and developing software systems in the financial services industry. He joined ExtractAlpha in 2016. Prior to that, he worked as a senior software engineer at HSBC Global Technologies. He holds a Master of Applied Science degree from Ryerson University specializing in signal processing.

Jackie Cheng, PhD

Jackie joined ExtractAlpha in 2018 as a quantitative researcher. He received his PhD in the field of optoelectronic physics from The University of Hong Kong in 2017. He published 17 journal papers and holds a US patent, and has 500 citations with an h-index of 13. Prior to joining ExtractAlpha, he worked with a Shenzhen-based CTA researching trading strategies on Chinese futures. Jackie received his Bachelor’s degree in engineering from Zhejiang University in 2013.

Yunan Liu, PhD

Yunan joined ExtractAlpha in 2019 as a quantitative researcher. Prior to that, he worked as a research analyst at ICBC, covering the macro economy and the Asian bond market. Yunan received his PhD in Economics & Finance from The University of Hong Kong in 2018. His research fields cover Empirical Asset Pricing, Mergers & Acquisitions, and Intellectual Property. His research outputs have been presented at major conferences such as AFA, FMA and FMA (Asia). Yunan received his Masters degree in Operations Research from London School of Economics in 2013 and his Bachelor degree in International Business from Nottingham University in 2012.

Willett Bird, CFA

Prior to joining ExtractAlpha in 2022, Willett was a sales director for Vidrio Financial. Willett was based in Hong Kong for nearly two decades where he oversaw FIS Global’s Asset Management and Commercial Banking efforts. Willett worked at FactSet, where he built the Asian Portfolio and Quantitative Analytics team and oversaw FactSet’s Southeast Asian operations. Willett completed his undergraduate studies at Georgetown University and finished a joint degree MBA from the Northwestern Kellogg School and the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology in 2010. Willett also holds the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) designation.

Julie Craig

Julie Craig is a senior marketing executive with decades of experience marketing high tech, fintech, and financial services offerings. She joined ExtractAlpha in 2022. She was formerly with AlphaSense, where she led marketing at a startup now valued at $1.7B. Prior to that, she was with Interactive Data where she led marketing initiatives and a multi-million dollar budget for an award-winning product line for individual and institutional investors.

Jeff Geisenheimer

Jeff is the CFO and COO of ExtractAlpha and directs our financial, strategic, and general management operations. He previously held the role of CFO at Estimize and two publicly traded firms, Multex and Market Guide. Jeff also served as CFO at private-equity backed companies, including Coleman Research, Ford Models, Instant Information, and Moneyline Telerate. He’s also held roles as advisor, partner, and board member at Total Reliance, CreditRiskMonitor, Mochidoki, and Resurge.

Vinesh Jha

Vinesh founded ExtractAlpha in 2013 with the mission of bringing analytical rigor to the analysis and marketing of new datasets for the capital markets. Since ExtractAlpha’s merger with Estimize in early 2021, he has served as the CEO of both entities. From 1999 to 2005, Vinesh was the Director of Quantitative Research at StarMine in San Francisco, where he developed industry leading metrics of sell side analyst performance as well as successful commercial alpha signals and products based on analyst, fundamental, and other data sources. Subsequently, he developed systematic trading strategies for proprietary trading desks at Merrill Lynch and Morgan Stanley in New York. Most recently he was Executive Director at PDT Partners, a spinoff of Morgan Stanley’s premiere quant prop trading group, where in addition to research, he also applied his experience in the communication of complex quantitative concepts to investor relations. Vinesh holds an undergraduate degree from the University of Chicago and a graduate degree from the University of Cambridge, both in mathematics.

Subscribe to the ExtractAlpha monthly newsletter